This exploration delves into the depths of what it means to embody bravery, drawing profound insights from the wisdom of two Black therapists and authors who have illuminated the Enneagram and its role in understanding how we navigate the world. This approach, inspired by works like "No Justice, No Peace" by Deborah Egerton and "The Enneagram for Black Liberation" by Chichi Agorom, offers a powerful framework for self-awareness, resilience, and collective liberation.

The Foundation: Understanding Fear and Our Protective Armor
Fear is a natural, biological response to threat, not a sign of weakness or moral failure. However, in systems that thrive on control, fear is intentionally cultivated. Authoritarian and fascist regimes, for instance, don't solely rely on force; they wield fear made ordinary, overwhelming, exhausting, and disengaging good people.

This chronic exposure to danger leads us to develop "armor" – patterns of behavior and personality traits that form as protection. The Enneagram offers a detailed map of these protective strategies, which can manifest in various ways:

• Perfectionism: Striving for flawlessness.
• Caregiving/People-Pleasing: Focusing on the needs of others.
• Excellence/Achievement: Driven by accomplishment.
• Knowledge/Intellectualism: Using understanding for security.
• Withdrawal/Observation: Detaching to gain perspective.
• Vigilance/Loyalty: Staying on guard and committed.
• Adaptability/Enthusiasm: Seeking positive experiences.
• Strength/Assertiveness: Projecting power.
• Disappearance/Peacekeeping: Blending in or avoiding conflict.
• Optimism/Joy-Seeking: Maintaining a positive outlook.

Beneath this armor lies a universal longing: to be safe, secure, seen, and loved unconditionally.
​
Justice, Peace, and the Indispensable Role of Truth
A crucial insight presented is that "peace is not the absence of conflict. Peace is the presence of justice." This redefines our understanding of tranquility, shifting it from a passive state to an active pursuit rooted in fairness. Furthermore, "justice always begins with truth."

When we experience fear, it is often a sign that we are paying attention to an unjust reality. Truth-telling is therefore presented not just as an act of honesty, but as "holy work." The video prompts introspection:

• What are you afraid of right now?
• What does your body know that your words haven't yet named?
• What truth about your life have you avoided because it felt safer not to name it?
• What has been normalized that is actually harming you?

Refusing to acknowledge these truths means choosing a lie that everything is fine, or that our struggles are simply a matter of being "tired" or "that's just how it is."

The Nature of Bravery: Beyond Fearlessness
Bravery is often misunderstood as the absence of fear, but the video clarifies that it is something far more nuanced and potent. True bravery is not about being fearless, constantly confronting, or sacrificing oneself to the point of breaking – these definitions often serve oppressive systems by ensuring resistance burns out.
Instead, bravery is revealed in:

• Staying Human: Maintaining empathy and connection.
• Discernment, Not Silence: Making conscious choices rather than passively staying quiet.
• Connection, Not Isolation: Building and nurturing relationships.
• Rest as Strategy: Recognizing the power of rejuvenation.
• Care as Resistance: Nurturing oneself and others.
• Telling Truths: Sharing information that sustains life.
• Risking Vulnerability: Acting without guaranteed outcomes.
• Holding Unpopular Opinions: Speaking truth to power when justice is at stake.

Bravery is often quiet, collective, and slow. It acknowledges fear not as a barrier, but as an emotion that can be present while still choosing connection and action.

Embodiment and Liberation
The journey toward bravery and justice is deeply embodied. Peace must be felt – in our shoulders, our breath, our nervous systems. If our bodies are perpetually braced and our spirits vigilant, justice has not truly reached us. Peace without embodiment remains mere rhetoric.

Liberation, therefore, is not about becoming someone new but about remembering our essential selves, shedding the armor and protections that no longer serve us. It involves:

• Trusting Inner Wisdom: Believing that the answers we need reside within us, accessible through embodied listening.
• Recognizing Our Worth: Understanding that worth is not transactional and that we belong, not because we earn it, but inherently.
• Speaking Our Truth: Recognizing that silence in the face of harm is not peace, and our presence matters.
• Challenging Survival Stories: Questioning narratives that say we must earn belonging, stay quiet, or carry burdens alone.

Finding Bravery in Action and Community
History offers countless examples of embodied bravery:

• Acts of Resistance: In Nazi Germany, bravery was hiding neighbors, passing information, and teaching banned ideas – small, relational acts rooted in conscience.
• Sustaining Community: During Apartheid, it meant protecting dignity, organizing quietly, and keeping culture alive.
• Showing Up Anyway: In the Civil Rights Movement, bravery was facing terror, holding each other, singing to regulate fear, and allowing rest so the work could continue.
• Modern Movements: The Black Lives Matter movement, fights for bodily autonomy, and advocacy for human rights worldwide demonstrate ongoing bravery in demanding change.

These acts remind us that bravery under oppressive systems is not about grand gestures alone but about sustaining ourselves, our communities, and our truth.
Personal Journeys of Courage
The video emphasizes that embracing our own journey involves discernment and courage:

• Divorce as a Brave Choice: Letting go of relationships that no longer serve, without villainizing those involved, is an act of bravery. It’s about recognizing that sometimes bravery means leaving, and sometimes it means staying.
• Ancestral Strength: Finding inspiration in the resilience and sacrifices of ancestors who navigated immense challenges.
• Seeking New Opportunities: Embracing change and transformation, even when it brings uncertainty.
• Rituals and Community: The power of ceremonies, like uncoupling rituals, to mark transitions and foster support.
• Self-Compassion: Learning to receive care, attention, and pleasure without needing to earn it.
• Sharing Wisdom: Understanding that insights and wisdom are meant to circulate and protect more than just ourselves.

Embracing Our Essence
​Beneath the armor, we discover not chaos, but our essence. This essence holds courage that is wise, love that is discerning, and power that is relational. Hope is not passive; it is a practice we must cultivate daily.
Justice does not ask us to disappear. Peace does not ask us to endure endlessly. Faith does not ask us to override our bodies. By understanding our fears, acknowledging our armor, and embracing the truth of our experiences, we can step more fully into our embodied bravery, fostering resilience, justice, and liberation for ourselves and our communities.

Emily Suzuki, MA

Fear is a familiar presence in therapy. Therapy is an invitation to explore our growing edges, the places that feel uncomfortable and scary. Often, that’s where our work begins and where we find the greatest growth.
 
Exploring fear is in the very DNA of the therapeutic relationship. Fear comes up often in therapy, and is present even before we seek out and take what we sometimes perceive as a risk, in asking for support. When we begin working with a therapist, someone who is initially a complete stranger, we may at first be guarded and protective of opening up and being vulnerable. Naturally, a dose of fear shows up to help us assess whether or not the person and relationship is safe and can be trusted.
 
As we build a relationship of trust, in which the therapist offers the reassurance that their support is rooted in compassion, non-judgement, deep and active listening, clients begin to feel safer. Within the net of safety and trust, client and therapist can begin to explore the layers of fear that may be showing up, both in the therapeutic relationship and in the client’s life.
 
Fear is an essential survival response to physical and emotional danger. When we experience a threat, our brains are wired to act in self-protection. This process has served us as far back as our ancestors, who had to navigate much greater physical threats.  Their survival level instincts turned on in the face of serious danger without so much of a thought, and their survival supported the evolution that led to our being.  Check out video about our triune brain by Dr. Nathalie Edmond at the end.
 
In our modern world, we may not be dodging tigers or samurais like our ancestors, but none the less, there is plenty of ways to feel unsafe in our society. While fear is a universal human emotion, each individual’s experience of it and relationship with it varies greatly. The intersections of one’s social location, identification with race, class, gender, sexual orientation, and ability, shapes our experience and threat to one’s safety. For those whose identities intersect marginalized groups, fear is a lived experience in a wholly different way than it is for those in the dominant groups. The insidiousness of systemic racism and white supremacy, is a system of power that is rooted in fear, in which police brutality is an everyday danger to those who are BIPOC (black, indigenous and people of color) and oppressed, and as a result creates and breeds more fear.
 
Fear shows up in so many ways, and can be a response to even small or imagined threats. Our nervous system kicks in with a fight-flight-or freeze response, always in service of our protection. However, this process can become so sensitive that it can be activated in moments when it’s not helpful to run, fight or freeze, and when turning towards and engaging whatever feels scary is more purposeful.
 
This is a place where we can develop a deeper understanding of our fear. Turning our attention inward and towards the fear, we can start to ask questions, and learn more about it. What is it truly afraid of? When is it showing up and getting in the way? How is it perpetuating old patterns and habits of not engaging with ourselves and others? In what ways might it be creating more pain and suffering?
 
When we feel safely held within a therapeutic relationship, one that is built on trust and safety, we can begin the process of inviting our fear into the room with us. Through noticing and gaining greater awareness of our fear (mindfulness), we can then practice disrupting the moments when fear attempts to turn us away from the work we need to do and instead, learn when it’s okay to trust, and bravely, lean into it.  

Learn more about the therapists at Mindful and Multicultural Counseling can help you transform your fear.  Read more about us here. Give us a call to begin the healing journey.